Skip to content
Enforcement · AEPD (Spain)

AEPD: RFEF requiring school certificate in addition to residence proof for minor

GDPRhub page Oct 7, 2026PS/00339/2024gdprhub.eu ↗

Holding

The DPA found the requirement by FIFA of proof of residence for a player whose registration is sought through a certificate of residence, a logical and reasonable exception to the prohibition of international transfers of minors. Nonetheless, according to the controller the school transcripts were required as supporting documentation, which implied that they are required in addition to the certificate of municipal registration. The DPA held that requesting and requiring both documents violated the principle of data minimisation, and deemed the requesting of one of the two documents sufficient to prove uninterrupted residence. This was considered in addition to the fact that FIFA’s guidelines explicitly state the alternative nature of the documents. Therefore, DPA held that the controller required, for player registration, documentation from the play which contained personal data exceeding what is officially required by FIFA. The DPA emphasised the importance of data protection for minors and how such a requirement involves more processing than necessary which could potentially expose minors to unnecessary risks. In light of the foregoing, the DPA fined the controller €100,000 for the violation of the data minimisation principle, enshrined in Article 5(1)(c) GDPR.

From GDPRhub’s case note — a summary of the decision, not its own words.

Full text

1/44  Case No.: EXP202318587 DECISION ON DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS Regarding the proceedings conducted by the Spanish Data Protection Agency and based on the following BACKGROUND FIRST: On November 29, 2023, a complaint was filed with the Spanish Data Protection Agency regarding a possible violation attributable to the ROYAL SPANISH FOOTBALL FEDERATION, Tax ID No. Q2878017I (hereinafter, RFEF or the respondent). The complainant states that he is a citizen (…) and the father of a minor under 14 years of age, who applied for a license from the respondent Federation to register with a soccer club in the province of ***PROVINCE.1. In response to this request, he was asked to provide documentation containing information regarding the minor’s academic history; documentation which he considers excessive. Upon contacting his daughter’s club, they informed him that such documentation is only requested from players who do not hold Spanish nationality and is intended to prevent the purchase of young talent in accordance with FIFA regulations. She points out that Spanish players need only provide a certificate of historical residency and that, although her daughter has (...) nationality, she was born and raised in Spain, and this can be easily demonstrated with the same evidence required of a player with Spanish nationality She states that she has contacted the respondent Federation to make a complaint about the request for documentation, and they cite FIFA regulations; however, she considers that these impose excessive requirements that are discriminatory in terms of the treatment of individuals based on their different nationalities, and points out that the aforementioned regulations make no mention of the school documentation required by the respondent Federation. He submits email correspondence exchanged with the respondent, FIFA statutes, and the Guide for Applying for the Registration of Underage Players. Specifically, the emails provided are as follows: - Email dated September 26 at 12:26 p.m. from the address ***EMAIL.1 to secretaria@rfef.es, which states the following: (…) My daughter is a citizen of (…) but was born in Spain and has lived in Spain since birth (…). To register her, they asked me for a series of documents, among which I was particularly surprised by a detailed account of her academic history. Upon further inquiry, I learned that the Federation requests this information for the purpose of preventing young players from being bought in one way or another by major clubs. (…) By requesting information in this manner, the Federation is going far beyond its authority. First, the information requested must be related to the purpose of the request. The purpose of the request is, 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 2/44 first and foremost, to allow my daughter to participate in the soccer competition, and her academic record and grades are irrelevant in this regard. Furthermore, the club has informed me that this information is requested only for players who are not Spanish nationals (…) Furthermore, this practice violates the principle of equal treatment between residents who are nationals of a country and other EU citizens, as established in applicable European legislation, as well as the right to the free movement of persons within the EU. - Reply email sent from the address estatutojugador@rfef.es to ***EMAIL.1 with copies to secretaria@rfef.es, estatutojugador@rfef.es, ***EMAIL.2, and ***EMAIL.3, dated September 26, 2023, at 3:59 p.m. with the following content: (…) Please find attached the Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players so that you may review Article 19. We are also attaching the FIFA Minor Player Guide, which specifies the documents that clubs must provide depending on the exception invoked (Art 19 of the RETJ), in this case, “5 Years of Uninterrupted Residence.” It is important to note that any minor player whose nationality or country of birth is other than Spain requires authorization from FIFA. Based on the foregoing, in accordance with Article 14 of the FIFA Statutes (see attachment), it is our duty to require the documentation specified in the guidelines; otherwise, FIFA could sanction the club and the RFEF. - New email from ***EMAIL.1 to secretaria@rfef.es, dated October 19, 2023, at 8:06 a.m., in which the complainant requests (…) a response to this email (for this purpose, he forwarded the email dated September 26, as previously mentioned). - Response dated October 19, 2023, at 10:31 a.m. from the address estatutojugador@rfef.es, which provided the following information: “(…) Please take note of the information provided in our email dated September 26, 2023 (see attachment). For the sake of efficient administration, we are once again attaching the authorization manual for minor players for the appropriate purposes (…) - New email from the complainant addressed to estatutojugador@rfef.es, dated the same October 19, 2023, at 12:39 p.m., in which he stated: (…) I understand that you are invoking FIFA regulations that would require you to follow this procedure. I have two comments in response to this: 1. The existence of regulations from a hierarchically superior organization can never be grounds for the Federation to act in violation of the law or European treaties. 2. In my opinion, the application of Article 19 of the RETJ does not imply that the documents to which I object must be requested from the player; rather, a simple certificate of historical residency would suffice. I see no reference anywhere in this regulation—in Art. 19, para. 3 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 3/44 and 4 of the RSTP, any reference to the school documents you have requested. I note that, although there is a procedure whereby players who have been residing in Spain for more than five years can be easily registered (Art. 19, paras. 3 and 4), it has not been applied in the case of my daughter and, as I understand from the club, it will never be applied. - Response to the preceding email, also dated October 19, 2023, at 1:19 p.m., stating the following: Please refer to page 9 of the manual and click on “FIFA Guide”; there you will be able to view the documentation required by FIFA. Furthermore, we inform you that the RFEF requires school transcripts as supporting documentation for the residency registry to verify SECOND: In accordance with Article 65.4 of Organic Law 3/2018, of December 5, on data protection and the Guarantee of Digital Rights (hereinafter hereinafter LOPDGDD), said complaint was forwarded to the RFEF so that it might analyze it and inform this Agency within one month of the actions taken to comply with the requirements set forth in data protection regulations. The notification of the referral of the complaint, which was carried out in accordance with the rules established in Law 39/2015, of October 1, on the Common Administrative Procedure of Public Administrations (hereinafter, LPACAP), was issued on December 22, 2023, as evidenced by the acknowledgment of receipt included in the case file. There is no record of a response to the issues raised in the letter forwarding the complaint. THIRD: On February 29, 2024, in accordance with Article 65 of the LOPDGDD, the complaint was accepted for processing. FOURTH: The Subdirectorate General for Data Inspection proceeded to conduct preliminary investigative proceedings to clarify the facts in question, pursuant to the functions assigned to supervisory authorities under Article 57.1 and the powers granted under Article 58.1 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (General Data Protection Regulation, hereinafter GDPR), and in accordance with the provisions of Title VIII of the LOPDGDD. The following background information is provided: - On December 22, 2023, the respondent was notified of the referral. On January 11, 2024, a letter was received from the respondent addressed to the Agency, in which the name of the minor was requested. - On January 24, 2024, a general reminder was sent with a new deadline (10 business days), and the specific request was stated as follows: “We request the procedure for registering foreign minors.” On February 1, 2024, another letter was received from the respondent requesting the name of the minor. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 4/44 On 05/20/2024, a request for information was sent to the respondent asking it to provide the procedure for registering foreign minors. On June 3, 2024, a written response was received in which they provided the “Procedural Manual for the Authorization of Minors by the RFEF” On July 5, 2024, a request for information was sent to the respondent asking it to provide the procedures for registering Spanish minors and non-EU minors. On July 16, 2024, a written response was received, from which the following information is extracted: - They resubmitted the “RFEF Procedure Manual for the Authorization of Minors” (Document No. 1). This document outlines the procedural protocol for the registration of Spanish and foreign minors. - They provide the “FIFA Guide to the Protection of Minors—Guide for Submitting Applications for Underage Players” (Document No. 2) - They state that: “…minors born in Spain with Spanish nationality who have never been registered with other National Associations do not require an International Transfer Certificate ; and, therefore, do not require any special authorization other than compliance with the regulatory requirements for processing their licenses. In short, the Procedure Manual attached herein does not apply to them.” Regarding Document No. 1: “RFEF Procedure Manual for the Authorization of Minors,” it details the specific documentation that the club must submit with each type of application, depending on the minor’s particular circumstances, which may be as follows: - Minors between the ages of 10 and 17 with Spanish nationality. - If a minor player is transferred internationally, the following exceptions: o Relocation of the parents for reasons unrelated to soccer. Art. 19.2.a) RETJ o The player is being registered for the first time and, prior to this application, has already lived continuously in Spain for at least five years. Art. 19.3 and 4. RETJ o The player is over 16 years of age and moves to the territory of the EU or the EEA. Art. 19.2.b) RETJ o The player and the club are within 50 km of a shared border, and the maximum distance between them is less than 100 km. Art. 19.2.c) RETJ C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es 5/44 o The player relocates for humanitarian reasons with his or her parents. Art. 19.2.a) RETJ o The player is relocating for humanitarian reasons without his or her parents. Art. 19.2.d) RETJ o The player is an exchange student participating in an academic program. Art. 19.2.e) of the RETJ With regard to Document 2: “FIFA Guide to the Protection of Minors—Guide for Submitting Applications for Underage Players,” the following is a summary of the relevant documents that must be included in the application depending on the various individual circumstances surrounding the international transfer of an underage player. FIFTH: According to the report generated by the AXESOR tool, the RFEF is an association incorporated in 1966, with a turnover of 139,710,909 euros in 2015. SIXTH: On May 20, 2025, the President of the Spanish Data Protection Agency Data Protection agreed to initiate disciplinary proceedings against the respondent, for the alleged violation of Article 5.1.c) of the GDPR, as defined in Article 83.5.a) of the GDPR. SEVENTH: After being notified of the aforementioned decision to initiate proceedings in accordance with the rules established in the LPACAP, the respondent filed a written statement of defense on June 6, 2025, in which, in summary, it stated the following: FIRST. – REGARDING THE REQUEST FOR A SCHOOL CERTIFICATE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS ESTABLISHED BY THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION (…), the provisions of the Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (hereinafter, the “RETJ”), approved and published by the International Federation of Association Football (hereinafter, “FIFA”), which has constituted, since 2001, the essential regulatory framework for governing the training, development, and mobility of soccer players at the international level. In particular, Article 19 of the RETJ generally prohibits international transfers of underage players. However, this article provides for certain limited exceptions, and the one applicable in the case at hand refers to the minor’s uninterrupted residence in the country of destination for at least the five years immediately preceding the application for registration (…) To clarify the application of these exceptions, FIFA published in September 2020 the Guide for Applying for Underage Players (hereinafter, the “Guide”), which expressly details the documentation required to demonstrate compliance with the requirements enabling the valid registration of minor players with soccer clubs. This Guide, which is official and binding in the international registration validation procedure, states on page 11 that proof of uninterrupted residence may be demonstrated, among other documents, by submitting 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 6/44  a recently issued certificate of registration with the municipal registry or equivalent document, indicating the start date of residence at the minor’s current address;  alternatively, school certificates issued and signed by the corresponding academic institution, which must clearly and continuously demonstrate that the minor has been enrolled at that school for, at least, the last five years without interruption. Although the Guide expressly mentions the possibility of providing a certificate of residence registration certificate or equivalent document and, alternatively, school certificates issued and signed by the corresponding academic institution, the fact is that the administrative and operational practice established by FIFA requires the submission of both documents as an indispensable condition for the validation of the registration application. (…) For this reason, the RFEF’s requirement to submit both the school certificate and the certificate of residence should not be interpreted as a discretionary or arbitrary decision; (…) it is included as DOCUMENT NUMBER 1 a compilation of various official requirements issued by FIFA, in which the Company is expressly requested to provide the school enrollment certificate for minors whose registration is to be processed through the RFEF, (…) in all of them, FIFA expressly requests the submission of the school enrollment certificate as documentation necessary for processing the minor’s registration, and that this request is made only after the minor’s certificate of residence has already been submitted, which reinforces the view that the requirement for the school enrollment certificate constitutes a standard practice systematically applied by that organization. (…) SECOND. – THE INSUFFICIENCY OF THE MUNICIPAL REGISTER AS EVIDENCE AS PROOF OF UNINTERRUPTED RESIDENCE (…) Various judicial rulings have held that municipal registration, while possessing administrative value, cannot be considered conclusive proof of habitual residence. This is because its validity rests fundamentally on a voluntary declaration by the citizen—albeit made in accordance with certain requirements—without requiring, in its ordinary processing, an effective verification of actual continued residence at the indicated address. From this perspective, it is fully justified for the RFEF to require supplementary documentation that allows for a more rigorous verification of the actual continuity of the minors’ residence. Delving deeper into this issue, it cannot be overlooked that the legal value of the municipal registry varies significantly, first and foremost, the nationality of the registered individual. It should be noted that one must consider the content of Article 18.2 of the same legal text, which clearly provides as follows 2. The registration of foreign nationals in the municipal registry shall not constitute proof of their legal residence in Spain nor shall it confer upon them any rights not already granted by current legislation, particularly with regard to the rights and freedoms of foreign nationals in Spain This point is of particular importance in the present case, given that the minor whose registration is being requested is a national of (...) and, therefore, her status must be assessed in accordance with the legal regime applicable to foreign nationals, C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es 7/44 (…) the Supreme Court, Social Chamber, which in its Judgement 276/2019, dated April 3 (Appeal 1299/2017), unequivocally holds that the provisions of the aforementioned Article 18, when regulating the effects of the registration of foreign nationals in the municipal registry, constitute a special rule that takes precedence over the general provisions established in Article 16.1. (…) And it concludes by clearly affirming in the Judgement clearly states: Registration on the municipal roll neither presumes nor determines the legal status of residence in Spain. (…) case law is crystal clear in denying that the municipal roll has full evidentiary value to prove continuous residence within the national territory, whether in the case of Spanish citizens or foreign nationals. (…) It is entirely understandable that the RFEF considered it essential to include in its Manual of Procedures for the Authorization of Minors (hereinafter, the “Manual”) a specific section regarding school documentation as a means of proving the minor’s uninterrupted residence, in accordance with the requirements established by FIFA itself within the framework of its authorization procedures—which have been referred to above—. Please provide an excerpt from the Manual in which, regarding the scenario of “First Registration” (a player who has not previously been registered with any club in any federation), sections 2 and 3 specify the following documentation to be submitted. - A document certifying the player’s residence (current municipal registry record showing the date of registration in Spain) - Documentation proving uninterrupted residence for at least 5 years in Spain (school transcripts signed and stamped by the relevant academic institution) (…) THIRD. - JUSTIFICATION OF THE NECESSITY OF THE PROCESSING IN QUESTION AND OF THE PROTECTION OF MINORS AGAINST ABUSIVE PRACTICES: the requirement for a school enrollment certificate (…) stems, above all, from a substantive purpose of comprehensive protection of the minor, promoted by the RFEF within the scope of its authority, in accordance with the principles that guide both its internal procedures and international standards regarding children. (…) Therefore, this is not a bureaucratic requirement, but rather a measure aimed at protecting the fundamental rights of minors and preventing possible situations of uprootment, exploitation, or dropping out of school. (…) In short, the request for a school certificate constitutes an active, necessary, and proportionate protective measure, whose sole objective is to ensure that federated soccer in Spain does not become a gateway to abusive practices, and that every registered minor participates under conditions of dignity, safety, and full respect for their rights. (…). FOURTH. — AGGRAVATING FACTORS ASSOCIATED BY THE AEPD WITH THE VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 5.1(C) OF THE GDPR 1. Regarding the alleged nature, severity, and duration of the violation (Art. 83.2.a GDPR) We cannot agree with the assertion that the RFEF has imposed an additional requirement—namely, the submission of a school certificate—on its own initiative, without a legal basis, and with seriously harmful effects on minors. (…) The requirement for said school certificate stems directly from the documentation requirements 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 8/44 established by FIFA, in the legitimate exercise of its regulatory powers in the area of international transfers of minors. (…) In this regard, there is no question of excessive data processing, given that the purpose of the processing corresponds to an international regulatory obligation, compliance with which is essential to formalize registrations under the terms established by FIFA. 2. Regarding the alleged negligence in the RFEF’s conduct (Art. 83.2.b GDPR) (…) the analysis conducted by the Agency is based exclusively on the resulting outcome, without taking into account in any way the prior, concurrent, or subsequent conduct of the data controller, nor to the due diligence measures adopted by the RFEF. Thus, the classification of the infringement is based exclusively on the alleged consequence of the processing (that is, the obtaining of the school transcript), without assessing the cause, the regulatory context justifying it, or the reasonableness of the processing carried out. (…) administrative violations cannot be classified under a regime of strict liability; there must be, at a minimum, an element of intent or a lack of due diligence in the violator’s conduct. (…) it is inappropriate to conclude that there has been negligence or unlawfulness in the RFEF’s conduct, given that  There is no intent in the processing;  The processing is in compliance with a regulatory mandate from a third party (FIFA);  No actual, specific, or proven harm has been caused;  And reasonable and proportionate measures have been taken to ensure compliance with the regulations (…) 3. Regarding the alleged infringement of minors’ rights (Art. 76.2.f LOPDGDD) The fact that the data subjects are minors cannot be considered in this case as an aggravating factor, but rather as an element legitimizing the processing, insofar as the purpose of the request for the school certificate is to ensure the effective protection of minors against abusive practices, uprooting, and exploitation for sporting or commercial purposes. (…) FIFTH. - REGARDING THE PRESENCE OF MITIGATING FACTORS NOT Recital (…) the data processing that is the subject of these proceedings was carried out in compliance with the requirements issued by FIFA, the governing body of international soccer, within the framework of its regulatory powers regarding the transfer and registration of minors. The RFEF, in accordance with this obligation, proceeded to incorporate the aforementioned processing into its Manual, ensuring full traceability, regulatory backing, and legitimate purpose, which demonstrates a diligent, transparent, and lawful exercise of authority by the controller. Likewise, it is an undisputed fact that the RFEF has not obtained any kind of benefit, direct or indirect, as a result of the alleged violation that is the subject of this proceeding, which demonstrates the absence of a profit-seeking or utilitarian motive in its actions. (…) it has not been subject to previous sanctions for similar acts, which confirms the absence of a history of violations in the area of personal data protection. (…) Likewise, it has been established that at no time were special categories of data processed, in accordance with the provisions of Article 9 of the GDPR, with processing being restricted exclusively to data necessary to comply with the formal requirement imposed by FIFA. (…) Furthermore, the Company has a data protection officer C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es 9/44 duly appointed on September 30, 2024, who performs his or her duties with full autonomy and independence, rigorously supervising compliance with data protection regulations by all relevant bodies within the organization. (…) SIXTH. – REGARDING THE CORRECTIVE MEASURES PROPOSED BY THE AEPD The RFEF insists that the school transcript is the ideal document to prove not only the minor’s presence in Spain but, fundamentally, the uninterrupted nature of that residence—an essential aspect for assessing the minor’s actual roots in the country. It asserts that this documentation not only meets the criterion of necessity under the principle of data minimization set forth in Article 5(1)(c) of the GDPR, but is also fully justified by the legitimate purpose of the processing: to ensure compliance with international regulations regarding the protection of minors in the sports context and to prevent irregular practices that compromise their fundamental rights. In this case, the proportionality of the processing is fully justified, as it involves a set of data essential for confirming the minor’s actual situation, from immigration, educational, and social perspectives. Attached to the brief are documents detailing what appear to be actions taken in connection with the registration of minor players: - A screenshot of what appears to be a computer application for the registration of players with the reference ***REFERENCE.1-First Registration - A communication dated October 19, 2023 (with FIFA letterhead, footer, and watermark) in which, with reference to the registration of a minor whose identity is withheld, the following is stated: (…) in accordance with Art. 29, para. 3(a) in conjunction with Art. 30, para. 3 of the Regulation on Procedure of the Football Tribunal (see also the FIFA Guidelines for Submitting Applications for Underage Players) and in order to evaluate your application, we kindly request that, within a maximum of six days from the date of this communication, you send us the following documentation via the TMS: • A copy of the player’s academic transcript (accompanied, if necessary, by a translation) for the 2018/2019 (academic) year, signed and issued by the relevant academic institution. (…) In this regard, should we not receive a response to this CFR via the TMS before the specified deadline expires, the application will be deemed withdrawn, and a new application must be submitted (see Art. 29, para. 3(b) of the Rules of Procedure). Finally, we are aware that the requested documents may contain classified information and data relating to confidentiality. Therefore, they will be treated with the strictest confidentiality and will only be used in connection with the application of the minor in question. In particular, they will not be disclosed, either in whole or in part, to third parties not involved in the decision-making process related to the application in question. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 10/44 There is no mention of the documentation previously submitted, even though the RFEF notes in its arguments—when explaining the content of the attached document—that FIFA expressly requires the submission of the school enrollment certificate as documentation necessary for processing the minor’s registration, and that such request is made after the minor’s certificate of residence has already been submitted, which reinforces the view that the requirement for the school enrollment certificate constitutes a standard practice systematically applied by that organization. Similarly, procedures for registering players are provided, with communications along similar lines as the following references: ***REFERENCE.2 (October 27, 2023), ***REFERENCE.3 (November 20, 2024) ***REFERENCE.4 (January 10, 2025) ***REFERENCE.5 (February 21, 2025) ***REFERENCE.6 (November 8, 2017), ***REFERENCE.7 (November 18, 2022) ***REFERENCE.8 (October 3, 2023) ***REFERENCE.9 (October 6, 2023) ***REFERENCE.10 (October 11, 2023) ***REFERENCE.11 (October 11, 2023). It should be noted that, while several files request a copy of the academic transcript— either on its own or with the stipulation that such documentation must clearly certify that the player has been enrolled at that academic institution for the past five years—as is the case with ***REFERENCE.1, ***REFERENCE.2, ***REFERENCE.4, ***REFERENCE.5, ***REFERENCE.7, ***REFERENCE.8, ***REFERENCE.9, ***REFERENCE.10, and ***REFERENCE.11—while others refer to a certificate of enrollment: ***REFERENCE.3 EIGHTH: On July 23, 2025, a draft resolution was submitted, proposing That the Presidency of the Spanish Data Protection Agency impose a sanction on ROYAL SPANISH SOCCER FEDERATION, with Tax ID No. Q2878017I, for a violation of Article 5.1.c) of the GDPR, as defined in Article 83.5.a) of the GDPR, with a fine of 100,000.00 euros. That the Presidency of the Spanish Data Protection Agency order ROYAL SPANISH SOCCER FEDERATION, with Tax ID No. Q2878017I, to demonstrate, pursuant to Article 58.2.d) of the GDPR, within a maximum period of two months, that it has implemented the following measure: - Adjust the processing of personal data it carries out and, specifically, the related to the registration of foreign minor players who have resided continuously in Spain for at least 5 years, to the requirements of the data minimisation principle set forth in Art. 5.1(c) of the GDPR. NINTH: Upon notification of the aforementioned proposed resolution in accordance with the rules established in the LPACAP, dated August 18, 2025, the respondent submitted a brief of arguments in which, in summary, it states the following - Violation of the principle of presumption of innocence and the right to judicial protection. It states that the RFEF is legally bound to follow the procedures 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 11/44 established by FIFA, with no leeway whatsoever to deviate from those requirements or to introduce its own assessment criteria. This is because it is FIFA that determines which documentation it deems relevant to prove the minors’ uninterrupted 5-year residence. In its view, the AEPD has not demonstrated why the data contained in both documents governing the registration of minor players would be inappropriate, irrelevant, or excessive in relation to the intended purpose, which is none other than to verify uninterrupted residence, in order to protect minors from abusive situations. In fact, they argue that even if both documents contained similar information, it could not be claimed that requesting both would entail an additional collection of personal data, since, in line with the AEPD’s line of argument, both documents contain the same personal data. The conclusion that one of the requested documents would not be justified makes it clear to this Court that the AEPD has maintained a completely rigid stance toward the RFEF, without disclosing the legal grounds that led it to do so, despite the powers conferred upon it under the provisions of applicable regulations. It points to a lack of justification in the reasoning set forth in the proposed resolution, which provides no evidence of the alleged violation. For all these reasons, it argues that it has not been proven or reasonably demonstrated that one can indeed conclude that, when both documents were requested, one of them was unnecessary. - They again allege an error in the assessment of the evidence provided, insofar as they consider that the Proposed Resolution does not, in their view, adequately assess the eleven documentary requirements that were submitted and which expressly state that FIFA has requested the submission of the school transcript for the minor whose registration was to be processed. In their view, these documents clearly and objectively demonstrate the established practice followed in international registration procedures for minors, demonstrating that the request for such documentation does not stem from an independent initiative by the RFEF, but rather complies with a repeated and express requirement by the world’s governing body of soccer, FIFA. They emphasize their instrumental role as a mere intermediary in the registration process, collecting the documentation on behalf of FIFA, which holds the decision-making authority. It notes that the Guide was published in 2020 and the reference pertains to the RETJ in effect at that time, which is available in the repository of official FIFA documents published on the website. This official FIFA document stipulates that the Transfer Matching System (TMS) application must be accompanied by certain required documents, including a copy of the document certifying the player’s residence and documentation of academic background. As proof that the Guide for the Protection of Minors remains in force, it is not only noted that it continues to be published among FIFA’s current documentation, but also that, 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 12/44 furthermore, the Guide on the International Transfer of Players published in 2024 expressly refers to the aforementioned FIFA Guide on the Protection of Minors. It is reiterated that the Guidelines expressly provide for the possibility of submitting a certificate of residence registration; however, the eleven documents prove that the reality is that FIFA’s established administrative and operational practice requires the submission of both documents as an indispensable condition for the validation of the registration application. What is relevant, in their view, for evidentiary purposes, is the existence of direct documentary evidence attesting to FIFA’s actual course of action, regardless of whether the Guidelines have yet been updated in their terms. Based on the foregoing, they conclude that the discrepancy between the letter of the Guide and actual practice has been proven by documentary evidence through the documents submitted. Additionally, they point out that the AEPD fails to consider an element of particular importance: the RFEF’s inclusion, in its Procedural Manual for the Authorization of Minors, of a specific section regarding school documentation as a means of proving the minor’s uninterrupted residence. This provision was incorporated in response to FIFA’s repeated requirements within the framework of its authorization procedures. Recital 1 states that the AEPD’s assertion that FIFA requests the school certificate (or academic transcript) only after the registration procedure has begun, as a means of correcting deficiencies, lacks evidentiary basis. For all these reasons, they emphasize that the omission or failure to provide documentary evidence in accordance with the parameters defined by FIFA results in the rejection of the registration application and, consequently, prevents the minor in question from participating in organized sports, thereby hindering his or her athletic and personal development. Regarding the argument raised by this Agency concerning the requirement to request this information from foreign nationals, it notes that the determining factor for requesting the required information in similar cases is the nationality of the minor applicant. In the present case, the applicant held (...) nationality and, for that reason, the aforementioned information was requested. It considers it a mistake to interpret this as a case of discrimination against the minor, when in reality it is an objective requirement established by FIFA in Article 19 of its Regulations. They reject the reliance on the judgement of the Court of Justice of the European Union of October 4, 2024, rendered in Case C-548/21, which, in their view, is inappropriate. This is because it interprets the provisions of Directive (EU) 2016/680, whose legal framework bears no relation to the processing carried out by the RFEF. - Lack of justification in the evidentiary assessment of the municipal registry as proof of uninterrupted residence It challenges the analysis conducted by the AEPD regarding the probative value of the municipal registry and argues that, since the individuals in question are minors, said regulatory reference is not 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 13/44 not only outdated but also legally irrelevant for assessing the evidentiary value of the registry regarding the uninterrupted residence of a foreign minor . On the other hand, while it is true that Art. 16.1 of the LBRL states that registration on the municipal roll constitutes proof of residence in the municipality, it does not, by itself, guarantee actual continuous residence or the resident’s legal status. For this reason, they understand that Art. 18.2 of the LBRL itself, in its current wording, clearly provides that the registration of a foreign national in the municipal registry shall not constitute proof of his or her legal residence in Spain nor shall it confer any rights not granted by current legislation. This special provision takes precedence over the general presumption of Art. 16.1 of the LBRL, demonstrating that the legislature intended to limit the legal effects of the municipal registry, especially with regard to foreign nationals. They also note that numerous judicial rulings have denied the municipal registry full probative value for establishing continuous residence or legal situations that require actual presence. Furthermore, they emphasize the complementary, non-exclusive nature of the registration certificate and the school certificate, which serve distinct purposes: the registration certificate attests to formal data but does not reflect temporary absences nor guarantee day-to-day physical presence. A minor may remain registered on their parents’ municipal registry even when temporarily outside the country (due to travel, stays abroad, etc.), since the municipal registry is not updated for short-term absences and relies on voluntary declarations of a change of address. For its part, the school certificate or transcript documents the minors’ continuous enrollment in Spanish educational institutions. In short, the residency registry and the school certificate are not duplicates, but rather complementary pieces of information. The RFEF has never labeled the municipal registry as “useless,” but rather as insufficient on its own. There is an essential difference between these concepts. The fact that a document is insufficient on its own does not mean that it lacks value when considered in conjunction with others. The municipal registry only certifies the date on which registration took place, which does not rule out the possibility that the minor may have lived in places other than Spain, without having reported her change of address. This is why, by also submitting the school certificate, it would be proven that since the registration in the municipal registry, the minor has continued to live at that same address during the subsequent years and, at a minimum, during the five years prior to the application. Therefore, only the combination of both documents serves to achieve the intended purpose, which is to prove an effective, habitual, and uninterrupted residence of 5 years. - Justification of the necessity of the contested data processing and the protection of the minor against abusive practices They request that the arguments contained in the brief of arguments regarding the Initial Decision be deemed reproduced here, with respect to justifying the necessity of the contested data processing, as well as the protection of the minor against abusive practices, which they believe have not been assessed by the AEPD. They also contend that the Proposed Resolution has not adequately addressed the arguments raised regarding the aggravating circumstances associated with the violations of Article 5.1(c), Regarding the nature, severity, and duration of the violation, we cannot agree with the assertion that the RFEF has imposed an additional requirement—namely, the submission of a school transcript—on its own initiative, without a legal basis, and with seriously harmful effects on minors. They reiterate that these are requirements established by FIFA in the legitimate exercise of its regulatory powers in the area of international transfers of minors. They also consider it inappropriate to conclude that there has been negligence or unlawfulness in the RFEF’s conduct, given that: • There was no intent in the processing; • The processing was in compliance with a regulatory mandate from a third party (FIFA); • No actual, specific, or proven harm has been caused; • And reasonable and proportionate measures have been taken to ensure regulatory compliance. In their view, assuming—in this context—that the existence of a specific processing activity —even if based on a regulatory obligation—automatically gives rise to a violation completely distorts the purpose of the GDPR’s sanctioning regime, violating the principles of culpability and proportionality enshrined in both European regulations and domestic law. They argue that the fact that the data subjects are minors cannot be considered in this case as an aggravating factor, but rather as an element that legitimizes the processing, insofar as the request for the school certificate is intended to ensure the effective protection of minors against abusive practices, uprooting, and exploitation for sporting or commercial purposes - Regarding the impossibility of implementing the corrective measures proposed by the AEPD This is because they insist that this is a measure required by FIFA and that failure to comply would have the practical consequence of the rejection of applications for registration. In the “Conclusions” section, it requests that the present disciplinary proceeding be dismissed, as there is no evidence to establish the existence of a violation of the provisions set forth in Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR. Furthermore, after reiterating the arguments presented in its conclusions, it requests that, in the event an administrative violation is found, the mitigating circumstances be taken into account, in accordance with Article 83 of the GDPR: good faith in its actions, acting in accordance with a request from a third party with regulatory authority, and a proactive commitment to regulatory compliance. This is done with the aim of reducing the penalty imposed. Attached is a communication dated August 6, 2025, with the subject line “Inquiry regarding authorization for minor players—Exception 19 of the RETJ.” In light of all the proceedings, the Spanish Data Protection Agency in these proceedings, the following facts are considered proven: 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 15/44 ESTABLISHED FACTS FIRST: The complainant is the father of a minor, born in Spain but of (...) nationality, who is a soccer player, and he requested his daughter’s registration with the Royal Spanish Soccer Federation (RFEF). In response to his request, the RFEF confirmed that Article 19 of the Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players applies to his daughter, which provides an exception to the prohibition on registering minors in cases of uninterrupted residence in Spain for a period of 5 years. SECOND: In order to proceed with the application, the RFEF required the complainant to provide a certificate of municipal registration and a school certificate for the minor whose registration as a professional soccer player is being requested. As informed to the complainant, the RFEF requires the school certificates as supporting documentation for the residence record to verify the uninterrupted 5-year residence. THIRD: The Guidelines for Submitting Applications for Underage Players, adopted by FIFA (in September 2020), state the following regarding the so-called five-year rule: Art. 19, paras. 3 and 4 of the RSTP “a player is registered player for the first time, and prior to this application, the player has already lived uninterruptedly for at least five years in the country where he is to be registered,” as follows: Circumstances: The player has lived uninterruptedly for the past 5 years prior to this application in the country where he is to be registered Documents to be provided: The player’s employment contract Document certifying the date of birth (the player’s birth certificate) Proof of the player’s identity and nationality Document certifying the player’s residence Application for approval of the first registration. The following explanatory note appears in the footnotes regarding the fourth document: The document certifying residence must be recently issued and must indicate the date the player began residing at the current address. Alternatively, the association may submit the player’s school transcripts, duly signed and recently issued by the relevant academic institution, provided they clearly indicate that the player has been enrolled at that institution without interruption for the past five years. (Underlining added by this AEPD) Therefore, FIFA requires proof of residence for the player whose registration is being sought through a certificate of residence. On the other hand, as an alternative to the certificate—that is, as an option to replace it, not as an additional document or, to use the RFEF’s terms, as supporting documentation for said certificate—the minor’s school transcripts may be submitted. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 16/44 FOURTH: FIFA published the aforementioned Guide with the aim of clarifying the application of these exceptions; it is official in nature and binding in the international registration validation procedure. LEGAL BASIS I Jurisdiction In accordance with the powers granted by Article 58(2) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (General Data Protection Regulation, hereinafter GDPR), grants to each supervisory authority, and in accordance with Articles 47, 48(1), 64(2), and 68(1) of Organic Law 3/2018, of December 5, on the Data Protection of Personal Data and the Guarantee of Digital Rights (hereinafter LOPDGDD), the Presidency of the Spanish Data Protection Agency has jurisdiction to resolve this proceeding. Likewise, Article 63.2 of the LOPDGDD provides that: “Proceedings handled by the Spanish Data Protection Agency shall be governed by the provisions of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, this Organic Law, the adopted to implement it, and, to the extent they do not contradict them, on a subsidiary basis, by the general rules on administrative proceedings.” II Preliminary Issues Article 4(1) of the GDPR defines “personal data” as: “any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person (‘the data subject’); an identifiable natural person is one whose identity can be determined, directly or indirectly, in particular by reference to an identifier such as a name, an identification number, location data, an online identifier, or one or more factors specific to the physical, physiological, genetic, mental, economic, cultural, or social identity of that person.” Article 4(2) of the GDPR defines “processing” as: “any operation or set of operations performed on personal data or sets of personal data, whether or not by automated means, such as collection, recording, organization, structuring, storage, adaptation or alteration, retrieval, consultation, use, disclosure by transmission, dissemination, or otherwise making available, alignment or combination, restriction, erasure, or destruction.” Article 4(7) of the GDPR defines the “controller” or “data controller” as: “the natural or legal person, public authority, agency, or other body which, alone or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing; if Union law Union or of the Member States determines the purposes and means of the processing, the controller or the specific criteria for its designation may be established by Union or Member State law.” 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 17/44 In the present case, in accordance with the provisions of Article 4(1) and (2) of the GDPR, it is established that personal data processing is taking place, since the RFEF carries out, among other processing activities, the collection and storage of personal data of natural persons, such as first name, last name, country of nationality, and place of residence. The RFEF carries out this activity in its capacity as the controller, given that it determines the purposes and means of such activity, pursuant to Article 4.7 of the GDPR. III Response to the Objections to the Decision to Initiate Proceedings In response to the complaints presented by the respondent, the following should be noted: First, the RFEF argues that the request for a school transcript stems from an established administrative and operational practice by FIFA, which requires the submission of both documents—a certificate of residence or an equivalent document, and school certificates issued and signed by the corresponding academic institution—as an indispensable condition for the validation of the application for registration. In support of this argument, the RFEF submits the documentation referenced at the end of the fifth background section, which pertains to the documentation submitted along with its written statement of defense. In this regard, it should be noted that, as indicated in the decision to initiate proceedings and as has been acknowledged by the RFEF, the regulations in force require, in the case of registration of foreign minors who wish to benefit from the exemption based on uninterrupted habitual residence , a certificate of municipal registration or equivalent document, or alternatively, school certificates issued and signed by the educational institution. In the decision to initiate these disciplinary proceedings, we noted that—in accordance with FIFA’s official statement—these are documents that may be submitted as alternatives—that is, one or the other document—and that, therefore, it could be considered a violation of Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR—as the RFEF is known to do—as stated by the complainant and acknowledged by the RFEF itself. In light of the foregoing, the RFEF submits, in support of its argument that it is FIFA that requests both documents, communications sent by that entity regarding specific player registration procedures. Regarding this documentation, the following should be noted: - Most of them were sent after FIFA had already adopted the Guidelines for Submitting Applications for Underage Players, adopted by FIFA (in September 2020). It can reasonably be understood that, if it were FIFA’s policy to require both documents, the Guidelines—whether in their original version or as updated— should have reflected that requirement. Not only that, but there is no record that 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 18/44 an updated version of the aforementioned Guide exists that includes this administrative and operational practice. This is necessary not only to provide legal certainty to the procedure but also to avoid potential breaches of other applicable regulations, such as the GDPR in the case at hand. In addition to the foregoing, it should also be noted that there is a version of the Guide published on FIFA’s website dated February 19, 2026. https://digitalhub.fifa.com/m/44f1e3b90feb5222/original/Guia-para-presentar- solicitudes-de-jugadores-menores-de-edad.pdf On page 13, regarding the so-called “five-year rule,” the following documents are listed as required (underlining and boldface added by this AEPD): List of Documents 1. The player’s employment contract This document is required only when registering a professional player. In such cases, the contract provided must contain all essential elements (including start and end dates, compensation, signatures, etc.), as well as any attachments. 2 Document certifying the player’s date of birth (birth certificate) The proof of date of birth must include the player’s date of birth and parentage. 3 Proof of the player’s identity and nationality An official identification card or a passport. 4 Document certifying the player’s residence The document certifying residence must have been issued recently and must indicate the date the player began residing at their current address. 5 Document verifying the player’s school transcripts for the past five years Alternatively, if the document certifying the player’s residence does not reflect his residence for the past five years, the association may submit the player’s school transcripts, duly signed and recently issued by the relevant academic institution, provided that they clearly indicate that the player has been enrolled at that institution without interruption for the past five years. 6 Request for Approval of Initial Registration - Requests for additional information documented by the RFEF refer, for the most part, to copies of academic transcripts, not school certificates. These two documents are different in nature, with the former containing much more comprehensive information (academic performance) that goes beyond the mere certification that a specific minor attended school at a specific institution and since when. It should be noted that the 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 19/44 requirement for personal data that exceeds the intended purpose of the processing constitutes a violation of Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR. - Furthermore, this AEPD has no evidence—beyond the mention in the pleadings that the certificate of residence for the minor had been previously submitted—of the documentation provided along with the enrollment applications that was initially submitted and prior to FIFA’s request for a copy of the academic record/school certificate of the minor whose enrollment is being sought. That is to say, and returning to the application procedure, in accordance with the criteria that they are public, official, and binding, both documents—the certificate of residence or the school certificate—may be submitted alternatively, according to the FIFA Guide (a document, we reiterate, that is public, official, and binding, as affirmed by the RFEF itself); therefore, the request for a school certificate in the registration procedures provided by the RFEF could refer to procedures in which either a certificate of residence or equivalent document has not been provided, or in which such a document, for reasons unknown to us and which it is not within the AEPD’s purview to assess, might be deemed invalid by FIFA. In other words, based on the documentation provided, it cannot be concluded that, in all cases where a certificate of residence or equivalent documentation for the data subject in question has been submitted, a copy of the academic transcript or school certificate is also required. This is because, as we have stated, the documentation provided does not indicate that the document—which, according to the FIFA Guide, is required as an alternative to the school certificate—had been submitted previously. - In addition to the above, it is also noteworthy that the request for a copy of the academic record/school certificate for the minor whose registration is being requested is made after the registration process has begun on the instance of the RFEF—that is, after the documentation that the RFEF considers necessary to apply for registration has already been submitted. The request for additional documentation by FIFA would amount to a sort of “correction of deficiencies” for the purpose of continuing with the processing of the application. Therefore, and in response to the RFEF’s arguments, it is striking that, if it is so clear to the RFEF that FIFA requires both documents, they were not provided at the outset of the process, thereby preventing the need for them to be requested once registration had been applied for. In this regard, let us recall that the application for registration filed by the claimant in September 2023 was met immediately with a request for a school certificate (not a copy of the academic transcript). This circumstance—given the dates of the registrations referenced in the document submitted along with the brief of arguments—most of which predate those of the claimant himself, REFERENCE.2 (October 27, 2023), ***REFERENCE.3 (November 20, 2024) ***REFERENCE.4 (January 10, 2025) ***REFERENCE.5 (February 21, 2025) ***REFERENCE.8 (October 3, 2023) ***REFERENCE.9 (October 6, 2023) ***REFERENCE.10 (October 11, 2023) ***REFERENCE.11 (October 11, 2023) It is worth questioning whether the ex officio request, based on an alleged requirement by FIFA, is actually the case. C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es 20/44 Regarding the argument concerning the insufficiency of the municipal registry as proof of uninterrupted residence and the application of Art. 18.2 of the LBRL to the registration of foreign nationals, it should be noted, first of all, that the wording of that provision prior to its amendment by Law 4/1996, of January 10, was as follows: 2. Foreign nationals who are of legal age and have a registered domicile shall have the rights and duties of residents, except those of a political nature. However, they shall have the right to vote in accordance with the terms set forth in the general electoral legislation applicable to local elections According to the explanatory memorandum of the aforementioned Law 4/1996, on the other hand, the distinction between “resident” and “domiciled person”—which was established because their rights and duties differed—is erased. However, the difference between these two concepts was more fictitious than real, since the rights and duties recognized for them were subject to the specific laws that implemented them. Thus, the current wording of Article 18.2 of the LBRL cannot be understood as having been motivated by the objective of diminishing the probative value of the voter registry—which, moreover, is expressly in Article 16.1 and with which it would contradict if the RFEF’s argument were accepted—but rather by the need to clarify the rights—primarily of a political nature, if we adhere to the wording of the first paragraph of the article 18—that might be granted to foreign nationals registered in Spain. Furthermore, it is worth noting the case law cited by the RFEF and, specifically, the Supreme Court Social Chamber Judgement 276/2019, rendered in Appeal 1299/2017. In this regard, it should be noted that this is a judgement aimed at unifying legal doctrine and that the Supreme Court itself states that the question raised—namely, whether, in order to prove legal residence in Spain for ten years as is required by Article 167-1 of the LGSS (Article 369 in the new Text), registration on the municipal registry during that time, or whether such registration is not valid for these purposes because the calculation must be based on the date of obtaining administrative residence authorization, which foreigners must obtain (…) This issue, therefore, is very different from the one raised in the present case. Finally, we must recall that we are dealing with the registration of a minor born in Spain, although of nationality (...). Since she is a national of a Member State of the European Union (***COUNTRY.1), we must recall the provisions of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union in Article 45, Freedom of Movement and Residence: 1. Every citizen of the Union has the right to move and reside freely within the territory of the Member States Article 21 (formerly Article 18 TEC) 1. Every citizen of the Union shall have the right to move and reside freely within the territory of the Member States, subject to the restrictions and conditions provided for in the Treaties and in the provisions adopted for their implementation. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 21/44 Let us also highlight some relevant rulings by the Court of Justice of the European Union, for example, the CJEU judgment of September 20, 2001, rendered in Case C-184/99 31. Indeed, the purpose of the status of citizen of the Union is to become the fundamental status of nationals of the Member States and to enable those citizens who are in the same situation to obtain, regardless of their nationality and without prejudice to the exceptions expressly provided for in this regard, the same legal treatment. 32. Thus, as the Court of Justice stated in paragraph 63 of the judgement in Martínez Sala, cited above, a Union citizen lawfully residing in the territory of the host Member State may rely on Article 6 of the Treaty in all situations falling within the scope ratione materiae of Community law. 33. Such situations include, in particular, those relating to the exercise of the fundamental freedoms guaranteed by the Treaty and those relating to the exercise of the freedom of movement and residence within the territory of the Member States, as recognized in Article 8a of the Treaty (see the judgement of November 24, 1998, Bickel and Franz, C-274/96, ECR p. I-7637, paragraphs 15 and 16). For its part, Royal Decree 240/2007, of February 16, on the entry, free movement, and residence in Spain of citizens of the Member States of the European Union and of other States party to the Agreement on the European Economic , states the following in Article 3—Rights—: 1. Persons falling within the scope of this Royal Decree have the right to enter, leave, move about, and reside freely within Spanish territory, subject to compliance with the formalities set forth herein and without prejudice to the limitations established therein. (…) 4. All Union citizens residing in Spain in accordance with the provisions of this Royal Decree shall enjoy equal treatment with respect to Spanish citizens within the scope of application of the Treaty establishing the European Community. This right shall extend to family members who do not hold the nationality of a Member State of the European Union or of a State party to the Agreement on the European Economic Area, who are beneficiaries of the right of residence or the right of permanent residence In other words, the conditions under which a national of an EU Member State exercises his or her rights in Spain must be equivalent to those applicable to a Spanish national. And this is without prejudice to the contradiction into which the RFEF itself falls when, in its email dated September 26, 2023 (3:59 p.m.), it states that it is important to note that any minor player whose nationality or country of birth is other than Spain requires authorization from FIFA”—a response that ignores the fact that the minor whose registration is being requested was born in Spain, as attested by the claimant and not disputed by the respondent. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 22/44 Furthermore, beyond the foregoing, it is not within the AEPD’s purview to determine which document may be required, in the case at hand, by the RFEF, for the purpose of proving a specific circumstance—uninterrupted residence during a specific period. On the contrary, what is being questioned in this proceeding is the requirement of two documents, both of which appear to serve the same purpose—a circumstance that would lead to the conclusion that one of them is not necessary. To the extent that both documents contain personal data, requesting both—as is the case in the matter under review in this disciplinary proceeding—would constitute a violation of the principle of data minimisation set forth in Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR. On the other hand, it is surprising that the RFEF insists—and even refers to it as such in its second argument—that the municipal registry is insufficient evidence to prove uninterrupted residence. This is because it would lead us to question why the document is requested if it does not serve the intended purpose. The processing of data unnecessary for fulfilling the intended purpose—in this case, the information contained in the municipal registry to prove uninterrupted residence—would constitute a violation of the principle of data minimisation as set forth in Art. 5(1)(c) of the GDPR. With regard to the argument concerning the necessity of the processing to protect the minor from abusive circumstances, we reiterate that it is not within the purview of this AEPD to determine which documentation the controller deems relevant to achieve a specific purpose, but it is within our purview to analyze whether the documentation required could constitute a violation of the GDPR by demanding an excessive amount of personal data in relation to the purpose of the processing. In this regard, and without questioning the interest in preventing abusive situations that affect minor players, we must point out that it may also be considered abusive toward these same minors for their personal data to be processed without adhering to the principle of data minimisation. Let us recall that we are dealing with a fundamental right whose compliance this AEPD is responsible for ensuring and which, ultimately, also prevents situations of abuse regarding the processing of the personal data of data subjects Regarding the argument concerning the aggravating factors noted in the decision to initiate this disciplinary proceeding, we must remind the RFEF that both the circumstance described in Article 83.2(a)—the nature, severity, and duration of the violation— as well as those under subparagraph (b) of the same provision are circumstances that have been taken into account in determining the seriousness of the conduct; they cannot be considered aggravating factors, in accordance with the provisions of Guideline 4/2022 of the European Data Protection Board on the calculation of administrative fines provided for in the GDPR, adopted on May 24, 2023. The aforementioned Guidelines address this matter in the following terms: (…) Under the GDPR, the supervisory authority must take due account of the nature, gravity, and duration of the infringement, taking into account the nature, scope, or purpose of the processing operation in question, as well as the number of data subjects affected and the extent of the harm they have suffered [Article 83(2)(a) of the GDPR]; whether the infringement was intentional or due to negligence [Article 83(2)(b) of the GDPR]; and the categories of personal data 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 23/44 personal data affected by the infringement [Article 83(2)(g) of the GDPR]. For the purposes of these Guidelines, the EDPB refers to these factors as the “seriousness of the infringement.” 52. The supervisory authority must examine these factors in light of the circumstances of the specific case and, based on this analysis, reach a conclusion regarding the degree of seriousness referred to in paragraph 60. In this regard, the supervisory authority may also consider whether the data in question were directly identifiable. Although these factors are addressed individually in these Guidelines, in practice they are often interrelated and must be considered in light of the facts of the case as a whole. It cannot, therefore, be argued that the AEPD is treating these circumstances as aggravating factors. That said, and without prejudice to the fact that it is not entirely clear within what framework FIFA requested this information in the previous cases cited for reference, as explained above, we continue to question whether the processing carried out by the RFEF can be deemed to comply with the principle of data minimisation, especially when, as has been verified in the very arguments presented by the RFEF, personal data is requested from the data subjects— in this case, the certificate of residence—which it understands is not necessary to achieve the intended purpose, namely to prove uninterrupted residence during a specific period of time. This conduct can only be considered negligent, not only because it involves requesting personal data that, in its own view, is unnecessary—as evidenced by the fact that it acknowledges such data does not serve the intended purpose—but also because it uncritically follows a —as defined by FIFA’s actions—without considering that it could constitute a breach of the regulations applicable to it as a Spanish entity, in this case, the GDPR. This is all the more true given that it has a data protection officer, as you have emphasized. Finally, it is clear that the conduct attributable to the RFEF involves the data of minors and, consequently, the circumstance provided for in Art. 76.2(f) of the LOPDGDD must be taken into consideration, this one as an aggravating factor. This is because it is undisputed that the data affected by the contested processing pertains to minors, and it cannot be argued, as the RFEF attempts to do, that this is due to an alleged protection against abusive circumstances. Let us recall once again that the fact that the personal data of the minors in question is processed without compliance with personal data protection regulations may also be considered abusive processing. A right which, let us recall, is considered a fundamental right and whose protection falls under the jurisdiction of the AEPD. In response to the allegation regarding the existence of mitigating factors that were not considered, the RFEF argues that it incorporated the required documentation into its Manual required, that it has not obtained any profit or benefit, that it has not been subject to previous sanctions, that none of the data processed falls under Article 9 of the GDPR, and that it has had a DPO since September 30, 2024. Regarding these arguments, it should be noted that the only official, binding 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 24/44 and available online is the FIFA Guide, dated September 2020 at the time of the events and currently in a version, with similar terms, dated February 19, 2026, which stipulates that the documents to prove residence and which we have repeatedly mentioned in this case must be submitted alternatively. The inclusion of a different criterion—that they must be provided not alternatively but cumulatively—in the RFEF Manual, which, we must point out, is not public, since only an excerpt from the it—3 pages long and containing no reference whatsoever to this requirement—cannot, in our opinion, be considered a mitigating circumstance regarding the violation committed. As for the absence of benefit or profit, it should be noted that the LOPDGDD (Art. 76.2 c)) provides that the benefits obtained as a result of committing the violation may be taken into account, and, therefore, to aggravate the offending conduct. Likewise, regarding the absence of prior sanctions, the EDPB itself, in the aforementioned Guidelines, states: The existence of prior violations may be considered an aggravating factor in calculating the fine. The weight given to this factor must be determined in light of the nature and frequency of the prior violations. However, the absence of prior violations cannot be considered a mitigating factor, since compliance with the GDPR is the norm On the other hand, although the data in question does not fall under the concept of a special category of personal data, we cannot overlook the fact that relevant personal information is being requested given the circumstances of the data subject—a minor— and therefore its significance cannot be downplayed. Finally, let us recall that the events at issue in this proceeding date from September 2023; therefore, it cannot be considered a mitigating circumstance that the RFEF appointed a DPO one year later, after it had become aware of the complaint filed with this AEPD. This is without prejudice to this Agency’s positive view of said appointment. Lastly, regarding the argument concerning the corrective measures contained in the decision to initiate proceedings, we must recall that these measures are linked to the infringement committed and, therefore, to the actions necessary to bring the infringing conduct into compliance with the requirements of the GDPR. Consequently, it is this AEPD that assesses the circumstances of the case and the infringement committed and, accordingly, determines the actions the respondent must take to comply with the GDPR. Consequently, in accordance with the provisions of the preceding sections, the arguments raised must be dismissed. IV Response to the Arguments Regarding the Proposed Resolution In response to the arguments raised regarding the proposed resolution, the following should be noted: 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 25/44 The RFEF begins by pointing to an alleged violation of the principle of the presumption of innocence and its right to judicial protection, all on the grounds that it considers itself a mere “executor” of the instructions given by FIFA regarding the registration of underage foreign soccer players. Recital 1: They contend that the AEPD has not demonstrated that the information contained in the documents—certificate of residence and school certificate—is excessive for the purpose of verifying the minors’ actual residence in the country where registration takes place and with the aim of protecting minors from abusive situations. The RFEF reiterates that it is legally bound to comply with the procedures established by FIFA, with no leeway whatsoever to deviate from these requirements or introduce its own assessment criteria; however, it appears to overlook that these procedures are those set forth in the Guide for submitting applications for minor players, adopted by FIFA (in September 2020), and that said Guide, as reflected in the third established fact of this resolution, indicates—with regard to the so-called “five-year rule”— five-year rule: Art. 19, paras. 3 and 4 of the RSTP, “the player is registered for the first time and, prior to this application, the player has already lived continuously for at least five years in the country where he or she is to be registered,” the following: Circumstances: The player has resided continuously for the last 5 years prior to this application in the country where he is to be registered Documents to be provided: The player’s employment contract Document certifying the date of birth (the player’s birth certificate) Proof of the player’s identity and nationality Document certifying the player’s residence Application for approval of the first registration. The following explanatory note appears as a footnote regarding the fourth document: The document certifying residence must have been recently issued and must indicate the date the player began residing at his or her current address. Alternatively, the association may submit the player’s school transcripts, duly signed and recently issued by the relevant academic institution, provided that they clearly indicate that the player has been enrolled at that institution without interruption for the past five years. (Underlining added by this AEPD) Therefore, as concluded in the aforementioned third party established fact, FIFA requires proof of residence for the player whose registration is sought in the form of a residence certificate. On the other hand, as an alternative to this—that is, as an option and to replace said certificate, not as an additional document or, to use the RFEF’s terms, as supporting documentation for said certificate—the minor’s school transcripts may be submitted. As we have already noted, the version posted on FIFA’s website—specifically the February 2026 edition of the Guide—makes a similar statement. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 26/44 Furthermore, let us recall at this point that the RFEF itself, in its written statement of objections to the decision to initiate these disciplinary proceedings, expressly stated that: “In order to clarify the application of these exceptions, the FIFA published in September 2020 the Guide for Registering Underage Players (hereinafter, the “Guide”), which expressly details the documentation required to demonstrate compliance with the requirements enabling the valid registration of underage players with soccer clubs. It also stated that this Guide was official and binding in the international procedure for the validation of registrations. It is this document—which was then deemed official and binding, as well as serving to clarify the exceptions provided for in the RSTP, that is now being sought to be undermined and, more importantly, limited in terms of the scope of its provisions, by seeking to replace it with what is termed an established practice followed in the international registration procedures for minors. Thus, the aim is to replace the legal certainty provided by the official and binding documentation—adopted to clarify the documents required for the registration process of minor players in the cases established in Article 19, paragraphs 3 and 4 of the RSTP with what it calls an “established practice” that, however, has not been endorsed through its incorporation into the repeatedly mentioned Guide in any modified version thereof. Likewise, the RFEF considers that the AEPD has not demonstrated that the requested documents are mutually exclusive in the sense that the information contained in one of them would be sufficient to achieve the intended purpose. In response to these arguments, we should recall that it was not this AEPD but FIFA itself that initially considered that only one of the two documents requested cumulatively by the RFEF would be sufficient to achieve the intended objective of verifying the minor’s uninterrupted residence during the last 5 years. In fact, it is FIFA itself that, in its oft-cited Guide, refers to alternative means to the certificate of municipal registration and school certificates. As stated in the third party established fact of this decision: The document certifying residence must have been recently issued and must indicate the date the player began residing at the current address. Alternatively, the association may submit the player’s school certificates, duly signed and recently issued by the relevant academic institution, provided that they clearly indicate that the player has been enrolled at that institution without interruption for the past five years. (Underlining added by this AEPD) Therefore, if two documents are both deemed sufficient to prove a given situation—with one serving as an alternative to the other—it is clear that requiring both amounts to a request for information—in this case, personal data of minors— beyond what would be sufficient to meet the required criterion. And, for this reason, in so far as both documents are not required by the RFEF as alternatives but rather cumulatively, such a request contravenes the principle of data minimisation set forth in Art. 5.1(c) of the GDPR. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 27/44 At this point, let us recall the terms of paragraph 2 of Article 5 of the GDPR: The controller shall be responsible for compliance with the provisions of paragraph 1 and shall be able to demonstrate such compliance (“accountability”). However, in this case, the RFEF, as the controller, has not been able to demonstrate compliance with the principle of data minimisation in the documentation required for the registration process of foreign minor players. In this regard, and in response to the RFEF’s argument—namely, that, in accordance with the argument put forward by this AEPD that both documents contain the same personal data, it cannot be maintained that we are dealing with an additional collection of data—we must state that at all time, this AEPD’s argument has been based on the purpose pursued at the time the personal data contained in the required documents is requested, and that this purpose is achieved—as indicated by the applicable official and binding documentation—with just one of the requested documents. It is, therefore, the purpose pursued by the processing that is achieved by requesting only one of the documents. And it is, therefore, this argument that allows us to conclude that there is no additional purpose that could be claimed to apply when a second document is also required. All of this is consistent with the fact that, as we have already pointed out and as the RFEF rightly recalls, it is not within the AEPD’s purview to determine which documentation the controller deems relevant to achieving a specific purpose. This is because it is FIFA that has already determined which documentation is necessary and, without wishing to be repetitive, has established that one of the two documents is required. The alleged lack of justification in the proposed resolution is unfounded, since that document sets forth in detail the arguments supporting the conclusion that the RFEF has failed to comply with the provisions of Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR, and this, it should be recalled, is based on the documentation provided by the RFEF itself, which, as we have indicated, has not refuted the fact that, by requesting information beyond what is established in the regulated procedure set forth in the relevant reference document—the Guide—it is in breach of the provisions of the aforementioned article. The arguments set forth in the preceding sections also address the points raised in the RFEF’s second defense. They emphasize the documentation provided in response to the initiation of this disciplinary proceeding, with which they seek to demonstrate that FIFA is, in practice, requiring the submission of the school certificate together with the certificate of residence registration. And all of this in accordance with what it calls established practice. In response to this, the RFEF seeks to have this AEPD give precedence to a practice over the official and binding instrument—which, therefore, guarantees legal certainty in the proceedings—that is applicable to the registration of minor players. It is therefore unacceptable to question this AEPD’s assessment since, conversely, this would amount to demanding that validity be granted to a practice—which, as such, has no legal basis and, furthermore, can be easily and 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 28/44 arbitrarily modifiable—be given validity over the instrument that the organization itself has adopted, through FIFA, to regulate the procedure. All of this is without prejudice to the irrefutable fact that, as the RFEF itself acknowledges, the Guide expressly provides for the possibility of submitting a certificate of residence. It is utterly surprising that the RFEF would characterize as relevant, for evidentiary purposes, the existence of direct documentary evidence attesting to FIFA’s actual course of action, regardless of whether the Guide has yet been updated in its terms. In other words, for evidentiary purposes, what is relevant in its view would not be the terms set forth in the Guide—which the RFEF itself acknowledges—but rather what it considers to be documentary evidence—with the deficiencies in such evidence that were already pointed out in the proposed resolution—and this regardless of the fact that the terms of the Guide have not yet been updated. On this point, the RFEF seeks to highlight as relevant the fact that said entity has included in its Procedural Manual for the Authorization of Minors, a specific section regarding school documentation as a means of proving the minor’s uninterrupted residence. This, it states, is in response to FIFA’s repeated requirements within the framework of its authorization procedures. Based on this fact, it rejects the AEPD’s exclusive reliance on the Guide published by FIFA as the sole valid regulatory instrument for determining the required documentation. This argument is clearly contradictory to the alleged instrumental role of the RFEF in the player registration procedure at issue in this disciplinary proceeding. Without prejudice to the assessment of this matter already set forth in the proposed resolution, we ask: if the RFEF merely complies with FIFA’s instructions and takes into account the terms of the Guide, can the RFEF include in its Manual documentation that has not been incorporated by FIFA itself? Can the RFEF, therefore, establish requirements that differ from those expressly set forth in the guide of the entity to which it is affiliated as far as this proceeding is concerned, and which FIFA itself had not modified at the time of the events with respect to its of 2020, nor has it done so in its new 2026 version? Such an argument cannot be accepted. With regard to the arguments concerning the minor’s nationality, the AEPD merely pointed out that, since she is a minor from an EU Member State, she is not legally considered a foreign national. Notwithstanding that the substantive scope differs, the fact is that the CJEU has already ruled on this matter, and did so in the terms already set forth in the proposed resolution. With regard to the probative value of the municipal registry, reference should be made to the arguments set forth in the proposed resolution. However, the RFEF insists on considering that the registry certifies administrative domicile for municipal purposes, but does not, by itself, guarantee actual continuous residence or the legal status of the resident. In fact, Art. 18.2 of the LBRL itself, in its current wording, clearly provides that the registration of a foreign national in the municipal registry shall not constitute proof of his or her legal residence in Spain nor shall it confer any rights not already granted by current legislation. This special provision takes precedence over the general presumption of Art 16.1 of the LBRL, demonstrating that the legislature intended to limit the legal effects of the resident registry, particularly with regard to foreign nationals. It also refers to case law in the social and administrative spheres, which has established that registration on the municipal roll neither presumes nor determines the legal status of the C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es 29/44 residence in Spain, emphasizing that to prove certain requirements (for example, the number of years of legal residence required for Social Security benefits), mere registration on the municipal roll is not sufficient. In response to this allegation, we must refer in general terms to the arguments already set forth in the proposed resolution on this matter. Likewise, we should recall that the present disciplinary proceeding is based on the failure to comply with the principle of data minimisation recognized in Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR as one of the primary obligations incumbent upon the controller. What is relevant in this case is that the RFEF is requesting cumulative data from two different documents—a municipal registration certificate and a school certificate—for a single purpose—proof of residence—for which it does not consider the first document adequate. That is, if the intent is to verify the minor’s actual residence and the RFEF considers that the certificate of municipal registration is not adequate for this purpose, why is it requested? If, in its opinion, the minor’s school enrollment certificate is the relevant document for proving his actual residence, why isn’t only this document requested? Especially since, as we have repeatedly stated, this is an option permitted by FIFA. Thus, it is not the AEPD that requires one document over the other, but rather FIFA itself in its Guide. Notwithstanding the previous argument—which, in our view, is central to these proceedings—the RFEF insists on emphasizing the complementary, not mutually exclusive, nature of the certificate of municipal registration and the school certificate, which, in its view, the AEPD fails to adequately appreciate. Recital 1 states that the AEPD interprets both documents as serving the same purpose and, therefore, that requiring both would imply that one is unnecessary. And that this assertion lacks evidentiary support. According to the RFEF, the municipal registry does not reflect temporary absences nor does it guarantee actual day-to-day presence. A minor may remain registered on their parents’ municipal registry even when temporarily out of the country (due to travel, stays abroad, etc.), since the registry is not updated for short-term absences and relies on voluntary declarations of a change of address. However, it should be noted that this same criterion could apply to school enrollment certificates, which, while they may document that a minor is enrolled in a specific educational institution, would not reflect possible absences, including those short-term (such as trips or stays abroad, etc.) referred to in the brief of arguments. Once again, it is emphasized that the joint requirement for both documents, therefore, responds to the need for rigorous verification of uninterrupted residence— as required by FIFA regulations—without taking into account that FIFA regulations, in fact, do not require both documents, but rather one or the other. Regarding the justification for requiring both documents, the AEPD reiterates that it is not its role to determine which documentation best serves the intended purpose. And this is without prejudice to the fact that if, as the RFEF appears to argue and as we have previously indicated, the school certificate is the one that best achieves the intended purpose—and since it is possible to request the school certificate rather than the municipal registry—let us recall once again that the guide refers to both as alternatives—the request for both implies, in our opinion, that even though it is possible to request 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 30/44 only one of these documents, both are being requested; therefore, the principle of data minimisation provided for in the GDPR does not apply. In the opinion of this AEPD, the argument that the residence registration certificate serves to verify the minor’s declared residence, and the school certificate serves to demonstrate the continuity of that residence, cannot be accepted. Therefore, only the combination of both serves to achieve the intended purpose, which is to prove an actual, habitual, and uninterrupted residence of 5 years. This is because the documentation proving the continuity of residence is based, precisely, on the proof of residence itself. In other words, a school certificate attesting that a minor is enrolled at a specific school presupposes that the minor resides within the municipal jurisdiction where that school is located. Ergo, the request for the school certificate would be sufficient to prove the situation that FIFA considers must be demonstrated. With regard to justifying the necessity of the contested processing and the protection of minors against abusive practices, we refer to the response provided to this issue in the proposed resolution, denying that the arguments presented were not properly evaluated. In this regard, we simply wish to reiterate that we are dealing with a fundamental right—the right to personal data protection—and that, just as in the case of potential abusive practices, minors must also be protected against actions that infringe upon their fundamental rights; in the case at hand, the fundamental right to personal data protection. This is all the more true given that there are, in fact, ways to reconcile the protection of both legal interests. With regard to the argument rejecting the aggravating factors taken into account when determining the penalty, it must first be noted that the circumstances described are not considered aggravating factors and were in no case were they classified as such, but rather as circumstances to be taken into account when determining the penalty applicable to the violation committed. As the arguments put forth in the objections to the decision to initiate proceedings are reiterated, we refer to what was stated in response to them in the proposed resolution. We would like to highlight, however, the wording used in the written statement of defense, which refers to a specific processing—albeit based on a regulatory obligation—in what could be understood as a linguistic slip, since what is actually officially established is the requirement for one document or another, as opposed to what the RFEF characterizes as an established practice which, in our view, cannot under any circumstances be classified as a regulatory obligation. In their argument regarding the impossibility of implementing the corrective measures proposed by the AEPD, they insist that the documentation whose request is being questioned is not a discretionary initiative of the RFEF, but rather a specific, repeated, and verifiable requirement on the part of FIFA, within the framework of the international procedure for validating the registration of foreign minors. They consider that requiring the RFEF to dispense with this documentation—or to impose a restriction on processing under the terms proposed by the AEPD—would place the organization itself in an untenable position from both an operational and legal standpoint. In this regard, we refer to the arguments set forth throughout this decision regarding the need to request the documentation—personal data—that 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 31/44 serves to meet FIFA’s requirement, which is none other than proof of the actual residence of the minor to be registered. Requesting personal data that does not serve that purpose constitutes excessive processing of personal data and, therefore, a violation of Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR. We emphasize that this is not, as the RFEF claims, a matter of asking FIFA to modify its established administrative practice for reasons of national data protection, but rather of complying—as the RFEF must, given its status as the controller—with the regulations governing the protection of personal data. In short, based on the arguments set forth in the preceding sections, it follows that the allegations raised should be dismissed. V Failure to comply. Data minimisation Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR states: "1. Personal data shall be: (…) (c) adequate, relevant, and limited to what is necessary in relation to the purposes for which they are processed (“data minimisation”);” If we examine the definition, we can deduce that only personal data strictly necessary for processing may be collected; that such data may only be collected when it is to be processed; and that it may only be used for the purpose for which it was collected, and for no other purpose. It is worth noting the considerations regarding the principle of data minimisation made by the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) in Guidelines 4/2019, “on Article 25, Data Protection by Design and by default,” version 2.0, dated October 20, 2020, adopted in fulfillment of the role entrusted to it by Article 70 of the GDPR to ensure its consistent application. Paragraph 74 of these guidelines states that: “First, controllers must determine whether they even need to process personal data for their relevant purposes. The controller must verify whether the relevant purposes can be achieved by processing less personal data, or by using less detailed or aggregated personal data, or without having to process personal data at all. This verification must take place before any processing, but may also be carried out at any time during the processing cycle.” And in section 76, these Guidelines 4/2019 indicate that “Essential elements of data minimisation by design and by default” may include, among others, the following: 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 32/44  Data avoidance: Any processing of personal data shall be avoided whenever possible to achieve the relevant purpose.  Limitation: The amount of personal data collected shall be limited to what is strictly necessary for the intended purpose.  Access restriction: Data processing shall be configured in such a way as to minimize the number of individuals who need access to personal data to perform their duties, and access shall be restricted accordingly.  Relevance: Personal data must be relevant to the processing in question, and the controller must be able to demonstrate such relevance.  Necessity: Each category of personal data must be necessary for the specified purposes and may only be processed if it is not possible to achieve the purpose by other means.” Therefore, it is necessary to carefully assess the information to be requested from data subjects, weighing the circumstances surrounding a particular processing activity and analyzing the consequences that access to certain data may entail. For its part, Recital 39 of the GDPR states that: “…Personal data must be adequate, relevant, and limited to what is necessary for the purposes for which they are processed.” In the present case, the facts set forth in the complaint reveal that the RFEF requires, for the registration of foreign minor players, certain requirements and, specifically, with regard to this case, a school certificate. According to the complainant, the RFEF requires these school certificates as supporting documentation for the residency record to verify the uninterrupted 5-year residence period. This reference to its nature as a supporting document for the residency registry seems to imply that such school certificates would be required in addition to, or as a supplement to, the certificate of registration. Given the foregoing, let us recall that the complainant’s minor daughter, although of (...) nationality, was born in Spain and lives in our country. In this regard, it is noteworthy, as we pointed out in Legal Ground III, that in its email dated September 26, September 2023, the RFEF informed the claimant that it is important to note that any minor player whose nationality or country of birth is other than Spain requires authorization from FIFA. As indicated by the RFEF, her registration with a soccer club in our country would be governed by the provisions of Article 19 of FIFA’s Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RETJ). This provision, the version of which in effect at the time of the events is dated May 21, 2023, states the following terms: 19 Protection of Minors 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 33/44 1. International transfers of players are permitted only when the player reaches the age of 18. 2. The following five exceptions are permitted: a) If the player’s parents move to the country where the new club is based for reasons unrelated to soccer. b) The player is between 16 and 18 years of age, and: i. the transfer takes place within the territory of the European Union (EU) or the European Economic Area (EEA), or ii. the transfer takes place between two associations within the same country. The new club must fulfill the following minimum obligations: iii. Provide the player with adequate soccer training or instruction that meets the highest national standards (see Article 4 of Annex 4). iv. In addition to soccer training or instruction, ensure that the player receives academic or school education, or training and education in line with his or her vocation, enabling the player to pursue a career outside of soccer should he or she cease to be a professional player. v. Take all necessary measures to ensure that the player is cared for in the best possible way (optimal living conditions with a host family or in club housing, provision of a guardian at the club, etc.). vi. With regard to the player’s registration, provide the relevant association with proof of compliance with the aforementioned obligations. c) The player lives in a home located less than 50 km from the , and the club of the neighboring association is also located less than 50 km from that same border in the neighboring country. The maximum distance between the player’s residence and the club’s residence shall be 100 km. In such a case, the player must continue to live at home, and the two associations in question must give their consent. d) The player holds a residence permit—at least a temporary one—in the destination country and/or has been recognized as a vulnerable person in need of protection from the government of that country after having fled his country of origin (or his country of previous residence), without his parents, for any of the following humanitarian reasons: i. his life or freedom is threatened on grounds of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or his political stance, or ii. any other circumstance that could seriously endanger his life. If the minor has been officially recognized as a refugee or a vulnerable person, he or she may be registered by either a professional club or an exclusively amateur club. No restrictions shall apply to subsequent domestic transfers that take place before the minor turns 18. If the minor has been officially recognized as an asylum seeker or has been recognized by the competent state authorities as a 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 34/44 vulnerable person in accordance with Article 19(d), he or she may only be registered by an exclusively amateur club. Such a player may be transferred domestically but may not be registered with a professional club until he or she turns 18. e) The player is a student and is temporarily moving without his or her parents to another country for academic reasons to participate in an exchange program. The duration of the player’s registration with the new club until he or she turns age of 18 or until the end of the academic or school program may not exceed one year. The player’s new club may only be an exclusively amateur club without a professional team or any legal, de facto, or financial relationship with a professional club. 3. The provisions of this article shall also apply to any player who has not previously been registered with any club, is not a national of the country in which the association with which he wishes to register for the first time is based, and has not lived in that country continuously for at least the past five years at a minimum. 4. If a minor player is at least ten years of age, the Player Status Chamber of the Football Tribunal must approve: a) his international transfer in accordance with paragraph 2; b) his first registration in accordance with paragraph 3, or c) his first registration if the minor player is not a national of the country in which the association with which he wishes to register for the first time is based and has lived continuously for at least the past five years in that country. 5. Approval in accordance with paragraph 4 is required before the association submits the CTI application or the initial registration. 6. If a minor player has not yet reached the age of ten, the association wishing to register the player—on the instance of its affiliated club—shall be responsible for verifying and ensuring beyond a doubt that the player’s circumstances strictly comply with the exceptions set forth in subsections 2, 3, or 4(c). Such verifications must be completed prior to registration. An association may apply to the Player Status Chamber of the Football Tribunal for a limited exemption for minors (“ELM”). a) The ELM, if granted, will exempt the member association from the obligations relating to the application set forth in paragraph 4, subject to specific terms and conditions and only for amateur minor players who are to be registered with exclusively amateur clubs. b) In such cases, prior to applying for the CTI and/or the first registration, the association in question must verify and ensure that, beyond any doubt, the player’s circumstances correspond to one of the exceptions set forth in paragraphs 2, 3, and 4(c). 8. Any club that registers a minor player following a domestic transfer, an international transfer, or a first registration must: - exercise due diligence with respect to the minor; - take the necessary measures to protect and safeguard the minor from any potential abuse; and - ensure that the minor has the opportunity to receive an (in accordance with the highest national standards) that will enable the minor to pursue a professional career beyond soccer. C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es 35/44 9. The procedure for filing a complaint with the Player Statute Chamber of the Soccer Tribunal regarding the matters described in this article is set forth in the Soccer Tribunal’s Rules of Procedure. It should be noted at this point that, as the RFEF indicated to the claimant in emails dated September 26 and October 19, 2023, the situation in which his daughter finds herself would fall under the category of “Uninterrupted Residence for 5 Years” For its part, the Guide for Filing Applications for Underage Players, adopted by FIFA (September 2020 edition), states the following regarding the so-called five-year rule: Art. 19, paras. 3 and 4 of the RSTP “a player is registered player for the first time, and prior to this application, the player has already lived uninterruptedly for at least five years in the country where he or she is to be registered” as follows: Circumstances: The player has lived continuously for the last 5 years prior to this application in the country where he is to be registered Documents to be provided: The player’s employment contract Document certifying the date of birth (the player’s birth certificate) Proof of the player’s identity and nationality Document certifying the player’s residence Request for approval of the first registration. The following explanatory notes are provided as footnotes: - Regarding the first document: This documentation is required only in the case of the registration of a professional player. In such circumstances, the contract provided must contain all (including start and end dates, compensation, signatures, etc.) as well as its annexes. - Regarding the second document: The proof of date of birth must include the player’s date of birth and parentage. - Regarding the third document: an official identification card or a passport. - And regarding the fourth document: The document certifying residence must have been issued recently and must indicate the start date of the player’s residence at the current address. Alternatively, the association may submit the player’s school transcripts, duly signed and recently issued by the relevant academic institution, provided that these clearly indicate that the player has been enrolled at that institution without interruption for the past five years. (emphasis added) According to the RFEF itself, in order to clarify the application of these exceptions, FIFA published in September 2020 the Guide for Applying for Underage Players (hereinafter, the “Guide”), which expressly details the 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 36/44 documentation required to prove compliance with the requirements that enable the valid registration of minor players with soccer clubs. This Guide, which is official and binding in the international registration validation procedure, stipulates on page 11 that proof of uninterrupted residence may be substantiated, among other documents, by submitting  a recently issued certificate of municipal registration or equivalent document, indicating the start date of residence at the minor’s current address;  alternatively, school certificates issued and signed by the corresponding academic institution, which must clearly and continuously demonstrate that the minor has been enrolled at that school for at least the last five years without interruption. (Underlining added by this AEPD) As we have previously indicated, the terms have not been modified in the new version of the guide dated February 19, 2026, and published on the FIFA website. Therefore, in the public, official, enforceable, and current document at the time of the events, FIFA requires proof of residence for the player whose registration is sought through a certificate of residence. This requirement, moreover, is perfectly logical and reasonable, as it constitutes an exception to the prohibition on international transfers of minor players, which is based on uninterrupted residence for a minimum period of 5 years in the country where registration is sought. Alternatively—that is, as an option to replace said certificate, not as an additional document or, to use the RFEF’s terminology, as supporting documentation for said certificate—the minor’s school records may be submitted. However, according to the facts presented by the complainant and confirmed by the respondent, the RFEF requires school transcripts as supporting documentation for the municipal registration record to verify the 5-year period of uninterrupted residence. This requirement is set forth in the document titled “Procedural Manual for the Authorization of Minors by the RFEF,” on page 9 of which the following is stated (the underlining is by this AEPD): The player is registered for the first time and, prior to this application, has already lived uninterruptedly for at least five years in Spain. Art. 19.3 and 4. RETJ First Registration (player who has not previously been registered with any club in any federation): - Document certifying the player’s identity and nationality. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 37/44 - Document certifying the player’s residence (current municipal registry record showing the date of registration in Spain). - Documentation proving uninterrupted residence for at least 5 years in Spain (school transcripts signed and stamped by the relevant academic institution). - The player’s birth certificate (must include the player’s date of birth and parentage). - Application for initial registration. - Document signed and stamped by the club explaining the circumstances and the date on which it first made contact with the player. - Affidavit signed before the general secretary of the corresponding regional federation or before a notary public, in which the player states that he has not been registered with any FIFA-affiliated club, signed by the player and by his parents. - The player’s contract if he is registering as a professional. It should be noted that, through this webpage, one can click on the FIFA Guide— an action that, incidentally, the RFEF encourages the claimant to take in its latest email dated October 19 October—which is none other than the aforementioned document, the Guide for Submitting Applications for Underage Players, and which does not indicate that it is necessary to provide the school certificate of the player requesting registration. In its arguments against the decision to initiate proceedings, the RFEF contends that the request for additional information —along with the certificate of residence—regarding the minor’s educational history is a consequence of a FIFA practice. A practice which, despite arguments to the contrary, and as we reasoned in Legal Ground III i), has not been reflected in an update to the Guide adopted in 2020, which remains the reference ii) from the examples provided, it does not unequivocally follow that it applies in similar cases such as the one involving the complainant. At this point, it is important to note the ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in its judgement of October 4, 2024, handed down in Case C-548/21. Although this judgement refers to Directive 2016/680 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data by competent authorities for the purpose of prevention, investigation, detection, or prosecution of criminal offenses or the enforcement of criminal sanctions, and to the free movement of such data, is perfectly applicable to the case at hand (emphasis added by this AEPD): 71 Thus, it follows from the very wording of Article 3(2) of Directive 2016/680 and, in particular, from the use of the terms “any operation,” “or set of operations,” and “any other form of granting access,” that the EU legislature intended to give a broad scope to the concept of “processing” and, consequently, to the material scope of application of that Directive. This interpretation is corroborated by the non-exhaustive nature—indicated by the word “such as”—of the operations mentioned in that provision [see, by analogy, the judgement of February 24, 2022, Valsts ieņēmumu dienests (Processing of personal data for Tax Purposes), C-175/20, EU:C:2022:124, paragraph 35]. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 38/44 72 Consequently, these textual elements support an interpretation according to which, when law enforcement authorities seize a telephone and manipulate it for the purpose of extracting and consulting the personal data it contains, they initiate processing within the meaning of Article 3(2) of Directive 2016/680, even if those authorities are unable, for technical reasons, to access that data. 73 This interpretation is supported by the context of Article 3(2) of Directive 2016/680. Indeed, pursuant to Article 4, paragraph 1(b) of that Directive, Member States shall ensure that personal data are collected for specified, explicit, and legitimate purposes and are not processed in a manner incompatible with those purposes. This latter provision enshrines the principle of purpose limitation [see, in this regard, the judgement of January 26, 2023, Ministerstvo na vatreshnite raboti (Biometric and Genetic Data Registration by the Police), C-205/21, EU:C:2023:49, paragraph 122]. However, the effectiveness of this principle necessarily requires that the purpose of the data collection be determined from the moment the competent authorities attempt to access the personal data, since such an attempt, if successful, may enable those authorities, in particular, to immediately collect, extract, or consult the data in question. 74 As regards its objectives, Directive 2016/680 seeks, in particular, as is apparent from recitals 4, 7, and 15 thereof, to ensure a high level of data protection for the personal data of natural persons. 75 However, that objective would be undermined if an attempt to access personal data contained in a mobile phone could not be classified as “processing” of that data. Indeed, interpreting Directive 2016/680 in that sense would expose the individuals affected by the attempt to access such data to a significant risk that a breach of the principles established in that Directive could no longer be prevented. Therefore, based on the established facts of this decision, the RFEF is requiring, in the context of the player registration at issue in this disciplinary proceeding, documentation containing personal data that exceeds what is officially required by FIFA, which constitutes a breach of the principle of data minimisation established in Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR. Classification of the Violation of Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR and Determination for the Purposes of the Statute of Limitations Article 83(5) of the GDPR classifies a violation of the following article as an administrative offense, which shall be punishable, in accordance with paragraph 2, by of up to 20,000,000 EUR or, in the case of an enterprise, an amount equivalent to up to 4% of the total annual global turnover for the previous fiscal year, whichever is higher: 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 39/44 "a) the basic principles for processing, including the conditions for consent pursuant to Articles 5, 6, 7, and 9;" For its part, the LOPDGDD, in Article 71, Violations, states that: “Acts and conduct referred to in paragraphs 4, 5, and 6 of Article 83 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, as well as those that are contrary to this Organic Law, constitute violations.” For the sole purpose of the statute of limitations, article 72.1 of the LOPDGDD provides as follows: “Pursuant to the provisions of Article 83(5) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, infractions constituting a a substantial breach of the articles mentioned therein and, in particular, the following: a) The processing of personal data in violation of the principles and safeguards established in Article 5 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679.” VI Penalty In order to determine the administrative fine to be imposed, the provisions of Articles 83(1) and 83(2) of the GDPR must be observed; these provisions state: “1. Each supervisory authority shall ensure that the imposition of administrative fines pursuant to this article for the infringements of this Regulation referred to in paragraphs 4, 9, and 6 is, in each individual case, effective, proportionate, and dissuasive. 2. Administrative fines shall be imposed, depending on the circumstances of each individual case, in addition to or in lieu of the measures referred to in Article 58(2)(a) through (h) and (j). When deciding on the imposition of an administrative fine and its amount in each individual case, due consideration shall be given to: a) the nature, gravity, and duration of the infringement, taking into account the nature, scope, or purpose of the processing operation in question, as well as the number of data subjects affected and the extent of the damages they have suffered; b) whether the violation was intentional or due to negligence; c) any measures taken by the controller or processor to mitigate the harm suffered by the data subjects; d) the degree of responsibility of the controller or processor, taking into account the technical or organizational measures they have implemented pursuant to articles 25 and 32; e) any previous infringements committed by the controller or processor; f) the degree of cooperation with the supervisory authority for the purpose of remedying the infringement and mitigating the potential adverse effects of the infringement; g) the categories of data affected by the infringement; 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 40/44 (h) the manner in which the supervisory authority became aware of the breach, in particular whether the controller or processor notified the supervisory authority of the breach and, if so, to what extent; i) where the measures referred to in Article 58(2) have previously been ordered against the controller or processor in question in connection with the same matter, compliance with those measures; j) adherence to codes of conduct pursuant to Article 40 or to certification mechanisms approved in accordance with Article 42; and k) any other aggravating or mitigating factors applicable to the circumstances of the case, such as the financial benefits obtained or the losses avoided, directly or indirectly, through the violation.” For its part, Article 76, “Sanctions and Corrective Measures,” of the LOPDGDD provides: “1. The penalties provided for in paragraphs 4, 5, and 6 of Article 83 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 shall be applied taking into account the criteria for determining the level of the penalty set forth in paragraph 2 of that article. 2. In accordance with the provisions of Article 83(2)(k) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, the following may also be taken into account: a) The ongoing nature of the violation. b) The connection between the violator’s activities and the processing of personal data. c) The benefits obtained as a result of the violation. d) The possibility that the data subject’s conduct may have contributed to the commission of the violation. e) The existence of a merger by absorption occurring after the commission of the violation, which cannot be attributed to the absorbing entity. f) The impact on the rights of minors. g) Having a data protection officer, when not mandatory. h) The voluntary submission by the controller or processor to alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, in cases where disputes exist between them and any data subject.” In the present case, in recital of the seriousness of the potential violation, with particular regard to the consequences it has on those affected, a fine should be imposed, in addition to the adoption of measures. The fine must be, in each individual case, effective, proportionate, and dissuasive, in accordance with the provisions of Article 83(1) of the GDPR. To ensure these principles, the RFEF’s annual revenue of 139,710,909 euros in 2015. Furthermore, based on the categorization of the violation, in accordance with Article 83(5) of the GDPR, the penalty imposed may be a maximum of 20,000,000 euros maximum, or, in the case of an enterprise, an amount equivalent to a maximum of 4% of annual turnover, with the higher amount being applied. Four percent of the turnover of 139,710,909 euros is 5,588,436 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 41/44 Therefore, the penalty imposed must necessarily range from 0 to 5,588,436 euros. It is considered appropriate to adjust the penalty to be imposed in accordance with the following circumstances, as provided for in the aforementioned provisions. • The nature, gravity, and duration of the violation, taking into account the nature, scope, or purpose of the processing operation in question, as well as the number of data subjects affected and the extent of the damages they have suffered (Article 83(2)(a) of the GDPR): based on the conduct described, the RFEF would be imposing an additional requirement—a school certificate— for the registration of foreign minor players who have resided continuously in our country for a period of 5 years, which, in addition to not being provided for by applicable international regulations and, therefore, is unjustified and would constitute excessive data processing—it causes considerable harm to players who find themselves in that situation. • Negligence in the infringement (Article 83(2)(b) of the GDPR): it is considered that the RFEF acted negligently by introducing an additional requirement for the registration of minor players who are not Spanish nationals but who have resided continuously in our country for five years, resulting in excessive processing of personal data that is not supported by applicable international regulations. This is all the more so given that it has incorporated this requirement into its Procedural Manual for the Authorization of Minors by the RFEF without, as we have stated, this incorporation being supported by the Guidelines adopted by FIFA. Likewise, the following aggravating factors are considered: • • The impact on the rights of minors (Article 76.2(f) of the LOPDGDD): specifically because non-Spanish minor soccer players are affected, as an an additional requirement, which therefore implies processing of data that exceeds the principle of data minimisation set forth in Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR The assessment of the circumstances set forth in Article 83.2 of the GDPR and Article 76.2 of the LOPDGDD, with respect to the violation committed by breaching the provisions of Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR, justifies the imposition of an administrative fine of 100,000.00 euros. VII Corrective Measures The text of the decision sets forth the violations committed and the facts that gave rise to the breach of data protection regulations, from which it is clear what measures must be adopted, without prejudice that the specific procedures, mechanisms, or tools for implementing them are the responsibility of the sanctioned party, as it is the controller of 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 42/44 data controller who fully understands its organization and must decide, based on accountability and a risk-based approach, how to comply with the GDPR and the LOPDGDD. In this case, the RFEF is required, within a maximum period of TWO MONTHS, counting from the date this decision becomes enforceable, to adopt and demonstrate compliance with the following measure: - Adjust the processing of personal data it carries out and, specifically, the related to the registration of foreign minor players who have resided continuously in Spain for at least 5 years, to the requirements of the data minimisation principle set forth in Art. 5.1(c) of the GDPR. The imposition of this measure is compatible with the sanction consisting of an administrative fine, as provided for in Art. 83(2) of the GDPR. Please be advised that failure to comply with any order to adopt measures imposed by this agency in the resolution of the present enforcement proceeding may be considered an administrative violation under the provisions of the GDPR, classified as a violation in Articles 83(5) and 83(6), and such conduct may lead to the initiation of further administrative sanctioning proceedings. Furthermore, please be advised that neither the acknowledgment of the violation committed nor, in this case, the voluntary payment of the proposed amounts, exempt the party from the obligation to take the necessary measures to cease the conduct or correct the effects of the infringement committed and to demonstrate to this AEPD compliance with that obligation. Therefore, in accordance with applicable law and after evaluating the criteria for determining the severity of the penalties for which the existence has been established, the Presidency of the Spanish Data Protection Agency RESOLVES: FIRST: TO IMPOSE on the ROYAL SPANISH SOCCER FEDERATION, with Tax ID No. Q2878017I, for a violation of Article 5.1.c) of the GDPR, as defined in Article 83.5.a) of the GDPR, a fine of 100,000.00 euros (one hundred thousand euros). SECOND: TO ORDER the ROYAL SPANISH SOCCER FEDERATION, with Tax ID No. Q2878017I, to provide proof, pursuant to Article 58.2.d) of the GDPR, within a maximum period of two months from the date this decision becomes final and enforceable, that it has complied with the following measure: - To adjust its processing of personal data, specifically those related to the registration of foreign minor players who have resided continuously in Spain for at least 5 years, to the requirements of the data minimisation principle set forth in Article 5.1(c) of the GDPR. THIRD PARTY: NOTIFY the ROYAL SPANISH SOCCER FEDERATION of this decision. 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 43/44 FOURTH: This decision shall become enforceable once the deadline for filing the optional appeal for reconsideration has expired (one month from the day following the notification of this decision) without the data subject having exercised this right. The sanctioned party is hereby notified that they must pay the imposed penalty once this resolution becomes enforceable, in accordance with the provisions of Art. 98.1.b) of Law 39/2015, of October 1, on the Common Administrative Procedure of Public Administrations (hereinafter LPACAP), within the voluntary payment period established in Art. 68 of the General Revenue Collection Regulation, approved by Royal Decree 939/2005, dated July 29, in conjunction with Art. 62 of Law 58/2003, dated December 17, by making a payment, indicating the taxpayer identification number (NIF) of the party subject to the penalty and the procedure number appearing at the top of this document, into the restricted account with IBAN: ES00-0000-0000-0000-0000-0000 (BIC/SWIFT Code: CAIXESBBXXX), opened in the name of the Spanish Data Protection Agency at the bank CAIXABANK, S.A. Otherwise, the amount will be collected through enforcement proceedings. Upon receipt of the notice and once it becomes enforceable, if the date of enforceability falls between the 1st and 15th of each month, inclusive, the deadline for making the voluntary payment will be the 20th of the following month or the next business day thereafter; and if it falls between the 16th and the last day of each month, both inclusive, the payment deadline shall be the 5th of the second following month or the next business day thereafter. In accordance with the provisions of Article 50 of the LOPDGDD, this Resolution shall be made public. Publication shall take place once it has been notified to the data subjects. Against this resolution, which concludes the administrative proceedings pursuant to Article 48.6 of the LOPDGDD, and in accordance with the provisions of Article 123 of the LPACAP, the data subjects may, at their discretion, file an appeal for reconsideration with the Presidency of the Spanish Data Protection Agency within one month from the day following notification of this resolution, or directly file a contentious-administrative appeal with the Contentious-Administrative Chamber of the National Court, in accordance with the provisions of Article 25 and paragraph 5 of the fourth additional provision of Law 29/1998, of July 13, regulating the Administrative Jurisdiction, within two months from the day following notification of this decision, as provided for in Article 46.1 of the aforementioned Law. Finally, it is noted that, in accordance with the provisions of Article 90.3(a) of the LPACAP, a final administrative decision may be provisionally suspended if the data subject expresses their intention to file a contentious-administrative appeal. If this is the case, the data subject must formally notify the Spanish Data Protection Agency of this fact by submitting a written notice to the Agency through its Electronic Registry web/, or through any of the other registries provided for in Art. 16.4 of the aforementioned Law 39/2015, of October 1. The data subject must also provide the Agency with the documentation proving that the contentious-administrative appeal has been effectively filed. If the Agency is not aware that the appeal has been filed 28001 – Madrid 6 sedeaepd.gob.es 44/44 within two months from the day following notification of this decision, it would consider the precautionary suspension to have ended. 938-101025 Lorenzo Cotino Hueso President of the Spanish Data Protection Agency C/ Jorge Juan, 6 www.aepd.es 28001 – Madrid sedeaepd.gob.es