Enforcement · Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante) EN LLM context A cited markdown file you can paste into your AI assistant (ChatGPT, Claude, a RAG or project knowledge base) to ground it in this document. Contains: this document’s text, its sections with their topics, and the full text of every law provision it applies. Everything links back to its source on overview.legal — legal information, not advice.

Dentist: Insufficient legal basis for data processing

The Italian DPA (Garante) has fined a dentist EUR 20,000.

€20,000 Fine
Dentist
ITALY
Art. 5 GDPR
Personal Data Processing Healthcare Supervisory Authorities
Jun 10, 2021 Source gpdp.it

Full text

The Italian DPA (Garante) has fined a dentist EUR 20,000. A data subject filed a complaint with the DPA against the dentist for refusing to treat him after the data subject had indicated he had HIV in his medical history form. In the dentist's clinic, it was common practice for patients to fill out a medical history form before medical treatment, which contained questions about previous, existing or suspected infectious diseases (e.g. tuberculosis, hepatitis, HIV). The DPA considered this to be a violation of the principles of legality. It stated that it was legitimate to ask for such information in order to better plan medical treatment. However, it was not permissible to collect such information and then refuse treatment to the patient.

Industry: Health Care

How it connects

References

Related across sources

C-169/23 Nemzeti Adatvédelmi és Információszabadság Hatóság v UC In Case C-169/23, the Court of Justice of the European Union (Third Chamber) ruled on a preliminary reference from the Kúria (Hungary) concerning whether the Budapest Metropolitan… CJEU ·Third Chamber Nov 28, 2024 Personal Data Legitimate Interest Supervision
C-203/22 CK v Magistrat der Stadt Wien In Case C-203/22, the Court of Justice of the European Union interpreted Article 15(1)(h) of the GDPR in response to a preliminary ruling from the Verwaltungsgericht Wien… CJEU ·First Chamber Feb 27, 2025 Profiling Automated Decision-Making Marketing
C-252/21 Meta Platforms v noyb C-252/21 (Meta Platforms (noyb)) CJEU Jan 12, 2023 Supervisory Authorities IP Address Supervision
C-115/22 SO The Court of Justice of the European Union (Grand Chamber) ruled on a preliminary ruling request from the Unabhängige Schiedskommission Wien concerning the interpretation of GDPR… CJEU ·Grand Chamber May 7, 2024 Supervision Criminal Data Processors
C-136/17 GC and Others v CNIL C-136/17 (GC and Others) CJEU Sep 24, 2019 Right to be Forgotten Legitimate Interest Criminal Data
2018-14 (15/01355) Personvernnemnda (Norway) - 2018-14 (15/01355) In 2017, the Norwegian DPA Datatilsynet found that a company "Legelisten", running an anonymous review website of healthcare personnel, lacked a legal basis for processing and… PVN Jan 21, 2019 Legitimate Interest Personal Data Controllers
Related documents